5 Signs Your Ad Creative Is Killing Your ROAS

Your targeting is right. Your offer is solid. But your ROAS is still terrible. The problem is probably your creative.

Ad creative is responsible for 50-80% of campaign performance. All the optimization in the world won't fix bad creative. Here are the signs yours needs work.

Sign 1: High CPM with Low CTR

CPM (cost per thousand impressions) tells you how much you're paying to show your ad. CTR (click-through rate) tells you how many people actually click.

If your CPM is high but your CTR is below 1%, your creative isn't stopping the scroll. People see it, ignore it, and keep scrolling. The platform charges you for impressions that don't convert.

The fix: Test new hooks. The first 3 seconds of video or the main image needs to grab attention immediately. Try bold claims, curiosity gaps, or pattern interrupts.

Sign 2: Good CTR but Low Conversion Rate

People are clicking but not buying. This means your ad promises something your landing page doesn't deliver. There's a disconnect.

Your creative got them interested in one thing, but what they found was different. That's a trust killer.

The fix: Align your ad message with your landing page. The headline, offer, and imagery should match. If your ad talks about a specific benefit, the landing page should lead with that same benefit.

Sign 3: Creative Fatigue

Performance was good, now it's not. Your frequency is climbing (same people seeing the ad multiple times) and your CTR is dropping.

The audience has seen your ad too many times. It's no longer new or interesting. They scroll past without thinking.

The fix: Refresh creative every 2-4 weeks. You don't need to reinvent everything. Sometimes changing the hook, the thumbnail, or the opening scene is enough. Test variations of winning concepts rather than starting from scratch.

Sign 4: Your Ads Look Like Ads

Polished, branded, obviously promotional content gets ignored. People have trained themselves to skip anything that looks like advertising.

The ads that work in 2026 look like organic content. User-generated style. Shot on a phone. Real people talking naturally. Less produced, more authentic.

The fix: Create UGC-style content. Use real customers or creators who match your target audience. Film in natural settings, not studios. Edit for social, not TV.

Sign 5: One Creative Running Too Long

You found a winner and let it run. Smart in the short term. But if you only have one creative carrying all your spend, you're one bad week away from disaster.

Even the best creative eventually dies. And when it does, you need backups ready to go.

The fix: Always be testing. Dedicate 20% of budget to testing new creative. Build a library of proven concepts you can rotate. Never depend on a single ad.

The Creative Testing Process

Here's how to systematically improve your creative:

Week 1: Review current performance data. Identify what's working and what's not. Look for patterns in your best performers.

Week 2: Create 3-5 new concepts based on your findings. Test different hooks, formats, and angles.

Week 3: Launch tests with equal budget. Let them run for 3-5 days to gather data.

Week 4: Kill losers, scale winners, document learnings. Repeat.

Creative Formats to Test

• Before/after comparisons
• Product demonstrations
• Customer testimonials
• Problem-agitation-solution
• Founder story
• Unboxing videos
• How-to tutorials
• Comparison to alternatives

Not every format works for every product. Test to find what resonates with your specific audience.

The Bottom Line

Bad creative is expensive. It wastes ad spend, burns through audiences, and makes every other part of your funnel work harder.

Invest in creative testing. It's the highest-leverage improvement you can make to your ad account.

‍